The Colonial Foundation: A History Forged in Profit and Coercion

The VOC and Early Introductions (1684-1800)

The origins of Camellia sinensis in Indonesia are distinct from the origins of its commercial industry. Tea first entered the archipelago not as a crop, but as a botanical curiosity. In 1684, German botanist Andreas Cleyer, working for the Dutch East India Company (VOC), brought tea seeds—allegedly the sinensis variety—from Japan. These were planted as ornamental plants in Batavia (now Jakarta). A monk, F. Valentijn, later reported seeing a sinensis plant in the courtyard of the VOC governor general in 1694.

Throughout the 18th century, the VOC was a global titan in the tea trade, but its relationship with Indonesia was one of logistics, not production. The VOC's lucrative tea trade was a direct link between Canton, China, and Amsterdam. Batavia served as a critical "supercargo" post and administrative hub, a way-station for managing this trade, not a center for cultivation. Any "factories" established during this period were for packaging, blending, or re-export of Chinese tea, not for processing locally grown leaf.

Cultuurstelsel (1830-1870): The Coercive Origin of an Industry

The commercial tea industry of Java was founded not on entrepreneurship, but on state-enforced coercion. Following the VOC's dissolution in 1799, its debts and possessions were seized by the Dutch government. To make the colony profitable and rescue the Dutch economy from the brink of bankruptcy, Governor-General Johannes van den Bosch implemented the Cultuurstelsel, or "Cultivation System," in 1830.

Known in Indonesia as Tanam Paksa ("Enforced Planting"), this system was a policy of forced labor. Javanese peasants were compelled to devote 20% of their village lands, or 66 days of labor, to cultivating government-mandated export crops—primarily sugar, indigo, and tea—instead of staple food crops.

This policy was the direct catalyst for the tea industry. Following a successful experimental planting at the Cisurupan Experimental Garden in Garut, West Java, in 1827, large-scale plantations were pioneered by the tea expert Jacobus Isidorus Lodewijk Levian Jacobson in 1828. Tea was officially integrated into the Cultuurstelsel, and the first shipment of processed Javanese tea was received in Amsterdam in 1835.

The Liberal Policy and Estate Expansion (1870-1940)

Humanitarian pressure and the rise of private business interests in the Netherlands led to the dismantling of the Cultuurstelsel. The 1870 Agrarian Law, or "Liberal Policy," ended the state monopoly and ushered in an era of private corporate investment. This new policy allowed European investors to acquire long-term leases on land, creating the vast, company-owned "estates" that define the industry to this day.

This policy shift coincided with a "Second Founding" of the industry: a pivotal agronomic pivot. In 1877, the Camellia sinensis var. assamica was introduced from Sri Lanka (Ceylon). This large-leaf variety, the backbone of the British colonial tea model in India, was found to be far more suitable for the Javanese climate and had significantly higher production than the original sinensis variety.

This 1877 decision to adopt *assamica* was a fundamental strategic choice that defined Indonesian tea for the next 150 years. The industry abandoned its sinensis potential (the variety used for green, white, and oolong teas) and instead modeled itself on the British, locking itself into a competitive path as a black tea producer for the bulk commodity market. This new, *assamica*-based model proved highly successful. It fueled a massive expansion, moving beyond Java for the first time as plantations were established in the Simalungun area of North Sumatra around 1910. By the early 20th century, the Dutch East Indies was a global tea power, the largest exporter in the world outside of British India and Ceylon.

---

The Long Decline and Modern Revival (1942-Present)

War, Independence, and Deterioration

The golden era of the colonial tea industry was brought to an abrupt and violent end by World War II and the subsequent Indonesian war for independence. Plantations were devastated, with large areas of tea torn up, some as part of a "scorched earth" policy by retreating Dutch forces.

The post-independence period (1945-1970) was a "dark age" for the industry. The newly independent nation faced decades of political and economic instability, and the tea sector suffered a "steady deterioration". This decline was driven by a cascade of systemic failures:

• A severe lack of investment for replanting and factory modernization.
• A "lack of expertise and research" as Dutch managers and agronomists departed.
• Cripplingly excessive taxation on the remaining estates.
• Crucially, "isolation from improvements in other major world tea areas".

By the 1960s, the industry was a shadow of its former self. Most tea plants were over 40 years old, well past their productive peak. By 1965, Indonesia's tea exports were just 53% of their pre-war volumes.

The 1970s Revival and State-Owned Enterprise (PTPN)

A coherent revival effort finally began in the 1970s and 1980s under the stability of the New Order regime. This "reboot" was financed with support from the World Bank and, significantly, "technical assistance from Sri Lanka".

The old colonial estates were nationalized and consolidated under a series of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) known as PT Perkebunan Nusantara (PTPN). This system remains the backbone of the formal estate sector today. A central holding company, PTPN III, oversees regional subsidiaries, such as PTPN VIII (managing the core West Java estates like Malabar), PTPN VI (managing the Kayu Aro estate in Jambi), and PTPN XII (managing estates in East Java).

While this revival saved the industry from collapse, the nature of the technical assistance—coming from Sri Lanka, a world leader in Orthodox black tea—reinforced the 1877 strategic path. The 1970s revival was a "missed opportunity" to fundamentally transform and diversify the industry. Instead of pivoting to specialty teas, the effort focused on rehabilitating and optimizing the existing *assamica* black tea model, making Indonesia a better black tea commodity producer but further entrenching it in that highly competitive global market.

---

Indonesian Tea Production: An Industry at a Crossroads

Key Production Metrics and Global Standing

The contemporary Indonesian tea industry is defined by a landscape of declining area and production, with an ownership structure dominated by smallholders. As of 2022, the total tea plantation area was 101,281 hectares. This land is primarily controlled by smallholder farmers (45.44%), followed by state-owned estates (34.49%) and private estates (20.07%). Geographically, the industry is highly concentrated, with West Java accounting for approximately 70% of all national production.

The production trend line is negative, showing a consistent decline in output in recent years, falling from 144,063 tons in 2020 to 122,700 tons in 2023. This decline in volume is mirrored by a precarious trade position. While Indonesia remains a net exporter, its $87.6 million in exports in 2023 were partially offset by $27.2 million in imports. These imports, primarily from China and Vietnam, fill gaps in the domestic market, particularly for green tea.

The following table synthesizes the key metrics of the Indonesian tea sector, illustrating the disconnect between volume, value, and market access.

Table 1: Indonesian Tea Production & Economic Metrics (2020-2023)

Feature	2020	2021	2022	2023	Data Sources
Total Production (tons)	144,063	137,837	124,662	122,700
Plantation Area (ha)	N/A	N/A	101,281	N/A
Global Production Rank	N/A	N/A	N/A	8th
Total Export Value (USD)	N/A	N/A	N/A	$87.6 Million
Global Export Value Rank	N/A	N/A	N/A	12th
Top Export Destinations	N/A	N/A	N/A	Malaysia, Australia, Russia

Manufacturing Profile: Orthodox vs. CTC

The Indonesian black tea industry has a split personality, employing two fundamentally different manufacturing methods that result in products for two different markets.

• CTC (Crush, Tear, Curl): This is a highly mechanized, industrial process designed for speed and efficiency. Leaves are passed through rollers that crush, tear, and curl them into small, hard pellets. This method is ideal for producing high-volume, "commodity grade" tea (fannings and dust) that yields a strong, dark, and consistent infusion. Its primary destination is the global tea bag market and low-cost blends.
• Orthodox: This is the "old school," traditional method of black tea production. It is a more delicate, labor-intensive process that involves withering, gently rolling, full oxidation, and drying. The goal is to preserve the whole leaf, which results in a more nuanced, complex, and aromatic tea. Orthodox tea is sold as high-value loose-leaf tea.

The large PTPN estates often run both methods simultaneously, segmenting their production by quality and destination. For example, within PTPN VIII in West Java, the Panyairan estate produces CTC, the Ciater estate produces Orthodox, and the Kertamanah estate is equipped to produce both.

Product Split: Black, Green, and Specialty

Indonesia's production profile is overwhelmingly weighted toward black tea, a direct legacy of the 1877 *assamica* pivot. Black tea has historically accounted for up to 93% of the nation's tea exports.

Green tea production is a smaller but significant secondary market. This production is primarily for domestic consumption. It is typically made using pan-firing (a Chinese method) and serves as the aromatic base for Teh Melati, or Jasmine Tea, which is immensely popular locally. In 2023, green tea accounted for only 7.4% of total exports.

This split reveals the industry's core contradiction: its export identity is an *assamica*-based black tea (competing with India and Kenya), while its domestic identity is a *sinensis*-based green tea (closer to China). The industry's historical failure was its inability to monetize its high-skill domestic green tea and specialty capabilities for the global market. A new, emerging category of specialty teas—including high-value white and oolong teas—is now being actively developed for export by PTPN, representing a strategic attempt to finally bridge this gap.

---

Comparative Regional Analysis: The Terroirs of Java and Sumatra

The Indonesian archipelago's two main tea-producing islands, Java and Sumatra, possess distinct terroirs, histories, and flavor profiles.

Java: The Historic Core

As the cradle of the industry, Java—and specifically the Preanger (Priangan) highlands of West Java—is the nation's historic heartland.

• Terroir: The region's character is defined by its high altitudes, with plantations in Bandung, Garut, and Puncak situated at elevations often exceeding 1,500 meters. The defining feature is the nutrient-rich, dark volcanic soil, a product of the 127 active volcanoes in the archipelago. This soil, combined with a temperate climate at elevation, creates ideal growing conditions.
• Flavor Profile: Javanese teas are known for their brightness and clarity.
  • Black Tea: Often compared to high-grown Ceylon teas, Javanese black teas are bright, brisk, and full-bodied. They are typically milder than robust Assams and are characterized by a light, delicate maltiness and floral notes, making them suitable for drinking without milk.
  • Green Tea: The green teas are described as "clean, bright," "refreshing," and carrying a "subtly sweet" flavor.
• Plantation Focus: Malabar Estate (PTPN VIII): The flagship estate of West Java, Malabar was established in the 1890s and brought to fame by its philanthropic Dutch planter, Karel Albert Rudolf Bosscha. Now managed by PTPN VIII, this high-altitude (1,550m) plantation produces a classic Orthodox black tea. Its "wiry" black leaves brew an amber cup. The flavor is famously "brisk" and flavorful, defined by a signature "woodsy aroma," "delicate maltiness," and "slight citrus notes".

Sumatra: The Robust Frontier

Tea cultivation expanded to Sumatra in the early 20th century, establishing a second, distinct production zone.

• Terroir: Like Java, Sumatra's terroir is volcanic. However, the climate is generally more humid and receives more rainfall, which contributes to a different flavor expression. The key growing regions are the Simalungun highlands in North Sumatra (home to the Sidamanik and Bah Butong estates) and the fertile plateau at the foot of the Mount Kerinci volcano in Jambi.
• Flavor Profile: Sumatran black teas tend to be darker, smoother, and more complex than their Javanese counterparts. The profile is often described as "dark, smooth, sweet, fragrant, [and] malty". These teas can carry deep, rich notes of molasses, fruit, and even cacao.
• Plantation Focus: Kayu Aro Estate (PTPN VI): This is arguably Indonesia's most celebrated and largest tea plantation (3,020 hectares), established by a Dutch company in 1925. Situated on a high plateau (1,600m) next to the Mount Kerinci volcano, Kayu Aro has a formidable heritage. It was historically marketed as a "quality no. 1 tea in the world" and was famously the "favorite tea" of the Dutch Royal Family, from Queen Wihelmina to Queen Beatrix. It was also a key ingredient for the high-end British brand "Teh Ty Poo". Its Orthodox black tea is known for producing a "clear orange" liquor with a "thick feeling on the tongue" and a "long lasting after taste".

The following tables provide a direct comparison of the two regions and the primary agricultural clones that underpin the entire industry.

Table 2: Comparative Regional Analysis: Java vs. Sumatra

Feature	Java (Primarily West Java)	Sumatra (North Sumatra & Jambi)	Data Sources
Historical Context	19th-century Cultuurstelsel core	Early 20th-century corporate expansion
Primary Terroir	High-altitude volcanic highlands (Bandung, Garut)	Volcanic soil, high humidity (Simalungun, Mt. Kerinci)
Key Historic Estates	Malabar (PTPN VIII), Kertamanah	Kayu Aro (PTPN VI), Sidamanik, Bah Butong
Black Tea Flavor Profile	Bright, brisk, delicate malt, citrus/floral notes, "Ceylon-like"	Dark, smooth, complex, sweet, rich malt, notes of cacao/fruit
Branding Story	"Colonial Heritage," Terroir, "The Bosscha Legacy"	"Royal Prestige," "World's Best" Quality, "Queen's Tea"

Table 3: Key Camellia Varieties and Clones in Indonesia

Variety/Clone	Date Introduced	Origin	Primary Use / Characteristics	Data Sources
C. sinensis var. sinensis	1684	Japan	Initial ornamental. Now used for some specialty green/white teas.
C. sinensis var. assamica	1877	Sri Lanka	The workhorse of the black tea industry; high-yield, robust, suitable for black tea.
GMB 7 (Clone)	1980s+	Gambung (Java)	A high-yield assamica clone (5,800 kg/ha/yr) from the Gambung Research Center; used for black, green, and white teas.
Yabokita (Clone)	N/A	Japan	Used in some estates (e.g., Jamus) for high-quality green tea production.

---

Key Challenges: A Sector Under Siege

Despite its rich heritage, the Indonesian tea industry is economically fragile and besieged by two existential threats: regulatory market-access barriers and intense domestic economic competition for land.

The Pesticide & MRL Barrier

Access to the world's most lucrative tea markets, particularly the European Union (EU), is contingent on meeting stringent food safety standards. The "most important" of these demands is compliance with Maximum Residue Levels (MRLs) for pesticides.

This complex and shifting regulatory landscape creates a significant "barrier to trade". A "lack of global harmonization" on MRLs—wherein the EU sets its tolerance levels "well below the internationally accepted standard"—imposes significant "costs of compliance" on tea exporters.

The Economic & Environmental Squeeze

While MRLs block access to foreign markets, a more pressing threat is eroding the industry from within. The Indonesian tea sector is "starting to lose its competitiveness" because it is losing the battle for its most essential asset: land.

• Land-Use Competition: Tea is no longer an economically viable crop for many landowners when compared to the alternatives. Across Indonesia, tea plantations are actively being converted to "oil palm plantations" or other "more profitable" products like vegetables.
• Government Policy: This land-use conversion has been an active component of government policy. Government land concessions for palm oil corporations now cover one-third of Indonesia's farmland. The official government stance has been that corporations—chiefly palm oil—are the "fastest machine to generate wealth". In this economic calculus, commodity tea simply cannot compete.

---

Future Outlook: A Strategic Pivot from Bulk to Brand

The New Strategic Imperative

The Indonesian tea industry cannot survive in its current form. Global market trends show that demand for "broken" black tea (the CTC/tea bag market) is expected to decrease, while consumer interest and willingness to pay are rising for green tea, specialty teas, and herbal/fruit teas.

The only viable path forward is a fundamental strategic pivot from volume to value. The industry must "Expand Branding and Marketing" because "bulk tea won’t cut it anymore". Consumers, particularly in high-value markets, demand a story, a brand, and a connection. This requires a corresponding shift in production, prioritizing high-margin Orthodox black tea and developing new capabilities in specialty teas like oolong and white tea.

The PTPN Pivot in Action

This strategic pivot is not merely theoretical; it is actively being implemented by the state-owned PTPN group.

• August 2023: PTPN Group, in collaboration with PT Suntory Garuda, announced its first-ever export of Oolong tea to Vietnam. This move signals a new, market-oriented focus. The PTPN Marketing Director explicitly stated, "This is our first experience in producing Oolong tea. We ventured into this production due to specific market demands, and we have the expertise to develop all types of tea according to buyers' requests".
• July 2025 (Projected): PTPN I launched its first premium export of "Heritage" Malabar tea, explicitly themed "A Cup of Truth, A Sip of Heritage". This branding effort is a direct attempt to attract high-value buyers in markets like Taiwan, Japan, and Europe, leveraging the estate's unique colonial history.

This new strategy aims to unlock the dormant value in PTPN's full portfolio of "heritage" retail brands, including Teh Kayu Aro, Tobasari, Goalpara, Walini, and Rollas, transforming them from domestic names into global brands.

The Path to Success

This pivot, while promising, is contingent on solving the industry's deep-seated structural and technical problems. A successful transformation will require:

• Solving the MRL Barrier: The most urgent task is to "Tackle Anthraquinone". This requires "scientific research and cleaner production methods" to ensure compliance and reopen access to the lucrative EU market.
• Investment in Infrastructure: The shift to specialty tea requires investment in modern processing facilities to support Orthodox, oolong, and white tea production, and to ensure quality control that prevents contamination.
• Upgrading Smallholder Practices: As smallholders control the largest share of land, they must be integrated into this new high-value model. This means encouraging a switch from seed-based planting to higher-yield, higher-quality clones.

---

Conclusion: From Colonial Commodity to Branded Heritage

The Indonesian tea industry, born from the 19th-century Cultuurstelsel as an extractive colonial commodity, is now in a precarious state of decline. Its 20th-century model—competing on volume in the bulk black tea market—has failed. The industry is squeezed by the superior economics of domestic crops like palm oil and locked out of high-value international markets by technical regulatory barriers like Anthraquinone.

The industry's survival is no longer a question of volume, but of value. The strategic pivot by the state-owned PTPN group, moving away from a failing bulk-commodity model and toward a high-value, branded, specialty model, represents the only viable path forward. This strategy correctly identifies that the industry's future lies in its two unique, inimitable assets: its terroir (the mineral-rich volcanic soil) and its history (the "royal prestige" of Kayu Aro and the "colonial heritage" of Malabar).

Success, however, is not guaranteed. The future of Indonesian tea rests entirely on its ability to execute this difficult pivot. It must solve its technical MRL problems to regain market access, invest in modern processing, and successfully transform a 19th-century commodity into a 21st-century luxury brand.

---

Works Cited

1. World Tea Expo Country Tour: Terroir and Organic Focuses of Indonesian Tea
2. Indonesian Teas: An Overview - History T Ching
3. Kayu Aro Tea - Nusakita - Article
4. Kayu Aro Tea, Kerinci Mountain, Jambi [Archive] - Indonesia Tourism Forum
5. Tea in Indonesia Report - Analysis of Plantations, Production, Consumption & Export
6. Business Transformation of PTPN VIII from Tea to Fruit - IPB University
7. Current status of Indonesian tea industry
8. Top 10 Largest Tea Producing Countries in the World | History of Ceylon Tea
9. Tea production in Indonesia - Wikipedia
10. Tea in Indonesia Trade | The Observatory of Economic Complexity
11. Indonesia's Tea Export Potential: Reviving a National Treasure ...
12. Palm oil: The myth of corporate plantation efficiency is failing ...
13. Educational - Bukit Sari Plantation (bukitsari.net)
14. Educational - Bukit Sari Plantation (bukitsari.net)
15. The Dutch East India Company's tea trade with China, 1757-1781 - Scholarly Publications Leiden University
16. Dutch East India Company - Wikipedia
17. Dutch East India Company | Facts, History, & Significance - Britannica
18. Cultivation System - Wikipedia
19. The Development Effects Of The Extractive Colonial Economy: The Dutch Cultivation System In Java - Harvard University
20. Indonesia - Culture, System, Diversity | Britannica
21. Indonesian Tea Development Outlook: Challenges and Opportunities
22. Indonesia's Tea Plantations: Steeped in Beauty - NOW! Jakarta
23. Indonesian Teas - Palais des Thés
24. What is Javanese Tea from Indonesia's Java Island? A Guide to Its ... - Teplo
25. World Bank Documents & Reports (PDF)
26. PTPN III (Persero), Holding Perkebunan Nusantara
27. Indonesia struggling to maintain tea production - Business - The Jakarta Post
28. Malabar Tea Plantation | Kertajati International Airport - West Java - PT BIJB
29. Around Kayu Aro tea plantation: a journey of the heart - Independent Observer
30. Processing Black Tea | PDF - Scribd
31. (PDF) Indonesian Tea Development Outlook: Challenges and Opportunities - ResearchGate
32. Contemporary Accounting Case Studies - FEB UI - Universitas Indonesia (PDF)
33. Black tea - Wikipedia
34. Quality characteristics of infusion and health consequences: a comparative study between orthodox and CTC green teas - NIH
35. Black Tea - Jokai Tea
36. Indonesia Black Tea Orthodox BOP I Sp - GlobalLinker
37. Global Green Tea Report 2024 - Firsd Tea
38. PTPN Group and Suntory Garuda Open New Market: First Export of ... - PRNewswire
39. Indonesia as tea producer | RealiTea
40. Indonesian Tea: Key Regions and Iconic Varieties - alveus.eu
41. What is Java tea from Java Island, Indonesia? - Teplo
42. Java Loose Leaf Tea - A Taste of Indonesia | High Teas
43. 13 Types of Indonesian Tea Worth Exporting to International Markets
44. Ingredients – East Java & Co - Tea
45. Java Malabar Plantation Black Tea – Simpson & Vail
46. North Sumatra, Indonesia - Teas - RateTea
47. Find Wellness in These 7 Indonesian Tea Garden Locations - Indonesia Travel
48. Sumatra Black Tea | Beautiful Taiwan Tea Company
49. Sumatra Hand-Rolled Black Tea - The Pleasures of Tea
50. A Day at Kayu Aro Tea Plantation - En.tempo.co
51. Comparison of green teas produced from C. assamica and C. sinensis - ResearchGate (Table 2)
52. Formulation of High-Quality White Peony Tea Made of Local Clones - Science Alert
53. GMB 7 clone in Jamus tea plantation... - ResearchGate (Figure 4)
54. Morphological Classification of Tea Clones... - ResearchGate
55. CBI Buyer Requirements: - Tea (PDF)
56. COMMITTEE ON COMMODITY PROBLEMS - FAO
57. When Life Gives You Lemons: How EU Citrus Standards Can Limit Trade - Princeton
58. New Strategy to Make Indonesian Tea Industry Become More Competitive and Sustainable
59. A Cup of Truth, a Sip of Heritage: PTPN I Exports Malabar Tea - Holding Perkebunan Nusantara