I. Introduction: The Double-Edged Sword of Oxidation

Following the cellular rupture of disruption, the tea leaf is biochemically primed for its metamorphosis. The oxidation stage is where the leaf's "grassy" and bitter-tasting polyphenols, primarily catechins like EGCG, are transformed by their own enzymes—polyphenol oxidase (PPO) and peroxidase (POD)—into entirely new classes of compounds. In oxidized teas, these are chiefly theaflavins (TFs), which provide brightness and a lively briskness, and thearubigins (TRs), which deliver dark color, malty depth, and body.

This "magical step" is, however, a double-edged sword. The art of the tea master is not simply to "allow" oxidation, but to actively control its trajectory and duration under specific environmental conditions. Every tea type has an optimal finishing point, and deviation in either direction—stopping too soon or letting it run too long—is the primary pitfall that dictates quality, creating signature flaws that are well-known to tea tasters. This analysis explores the distinct dangers of under- and over-oxidation for green, oolong, and black teas.

II. The Pitfall of Prevention: Under- and Over-Fixing Green Tea

For green tea, the goal is the absolute prevention of enzymatic oxidation to preserve the leaf's "natural form". The defining process is "kill-green," or Shaqing, where high heat is applied before any significant rolling to denature the PPO and POD enzymes. This "fixing" is the primary pitfall.

Pitfall 1: Under-Fixing (Under-oxidation)

If the heat is insufficient in temperature or duration, it is considered "under-fixing". This is a catastrophic flaw, as the oxidative enzymes are not fully denatured and "residual enzyme activities" remain. While the tea may appear green initially, it is unstable. These active enzymes will continue to oxidize the catechins during storage, leading to the "browning of green teas". The final product loses its vibrant green color, its "fresh and invigorating" character, and its delicate, grassy notes, developing a dull appearance and a compromised flavor.

Pitfall 2: Over-Fixing (Over-heating)

The opposite danger is applying too much heat. This "scorches the leaf", resulting in a "smoky taste". While the enzymes are certainly denatured, the excessive heat also destroys the desirable, "diverse aroma" compounds that the tea master seeks to preserve. In Japanese steamed teas, this can eliminate the bright, vegetal notes, while in Chinese pan-fired teas, it can overwhelm the gentle "toasty notes" with an acrid, burnt character.

III. The Oolong Tightrope: Navigating Partial Oxidation

Oolong tea represents the most complex expression of the tea master's art, as the goal is a precise partial oxidation, which can range from as little as 8% to as much as 80%. This is achieved through a meticulous and iterative process of gentle bruising (Yaoqing) followed by periods of rest (Tanliang). The tea master must stop this process based on sensory cues, primarily the development of specific aromas. This creates a razor-thin margin for error.

Pitfall 1: Under-Oxidation (Stopping too soon)

If the master "fixes" the leaf too early, the tea remains too close to a green tea. The resulting flavor profile will be "fresh and grassy" or "light and flowery", but it will be one-dimensional. It fails to develop the signature "fruity, milky, or even woody notes" or the "earthy, nutty, and sometimes toasty" depth that defines the oolong category. The unique chemical transformation that creates oolong-specific compounds like theasinensins and oolongtheanins is cut short, resulting in a bland, simple tea that lacks the intended complexity.

Pitfall 2: Over-Oxidation (Stopping too late)

This is the more common pitfall, where the oxidation is allowed to run too long. The tea crosses the boundary from "semi-fermented" to "fully fermented". The flavor profile "comes closer to Black teas," losing its delicate floral nuances and instead developing a "full bodied profile" and a "malt aroma". The leaf itself, which should famously have "red edges and a green center", becomes uniformly dark. The tea master has essentially missed the mark and created a low-quality black tea, having completely lost the unique, layered aromatic profile that is the entire purpose of oolong manufacturing.

IV. Black Tea: The Dangers of "Completion"

The oxidation of black tea is often described as "full" or "complete". However, this is a dangerous simplification. The true goal is not "completion" but the achievement of an optimal ratio of theaflavins (TFs) to thearubigins (TRs), often cited as an ideal 1:10. This process is a carefully managed kinetic race. PPO is the primary enzyme that converts catechins into TFs (briskness). Simultaneously, PPO's reaction generates hydrogen peroxide ($H_2O_2$). This $H_2O_2$ then "fuels" the POD enzyme, which degrades the newly formed TFs, polymerizing them into TRs (color and body).

Pitfall 1: Under-Oxidation (Under-fermentation)

If the process is stopped too early (e.g., by drying), the enzymatic conversion is insufficient. The resulting liquor will be weak and thin, lacking the "thick" body and deep, malty notes expected of black tea. Most notably, it will retain a "metallic and green taste" due to the high levels of un-oxidized catechins, which are "colorless, water-soluble compounds that contribute bitterness and astringency to green tea infusion".

Pitfall 2: Over-Oxidation (Over-fermentation)

This is the critical pitfall in black tea production. If the process runs too long, the synergistic PPO/POD cascade becomes destructive. POD, fueled by a continuous supply of $H_2O_2$ from PPO, consumes the desirable TFs, converting them all into TRs. The TF/TR ratio is ruined. The resulting tea is "over-fermented". It will be dark and possess "body", but it will be "too soft," "dull," and "flat," having lost all of its "briskness". It is a tea without vibrancy that "don't retain flavour for long".

V. Environmental Pitfalls: The Unseen Variables

Beyond timing, the tea master must manage the oxidation environment itself. Failure to control these variables can lead to pitfalls, regardless of timing.

• Temperature: This is a key control. Higher temperatures (e.g., 35°C) accelerate oxidation, rapidly increasing TRs (body) but also leading to enzyme instability. Conversely, lower temperatures (e.g., 20-25°C) are considered "suitable for manufacturing quality black tea" because enzyme stability is higher. This allows for a slower, more controlled reaction that forms a "maximum amount" of TFs and a better TF/TR ratio, resulting in more "brightness". The pitfall is fermenting too hot, which "cooks" the tea, degrades TFs, and produces a dull liquor.
• Humidity: For black tea, high humidity (95-98%) is essential. The pitfall is allowing dry air to pass over the leaves. This "interferes with the rate of oxidation" and causes the leaves to dry out, which "leads to blackening" and a "prickly feel", prematurely halting the enzymatic process.
• Oxygen: As oxidation is an enzymatic reaction with oxygen as a substrate, an "adequate amount of oxygen" is fundamental. Insufficient airflow (a common pitfall in "piling") can starve the reaction, slowing it and altering the final chemical profile.

VI. Conclusion

Oxidation is not a simple, linear "on-switch" but a highly complex and sensitive biochemical cascade that defines the final character of tea. The "art of the tea master" is, in essence, the art of applied biochemistry: a sensory-guided navigation of time, temperature, and humidity to avoid the distinct pitfalls of "too much" and "too little." An under-fixed green tea becomes an unstable, browning failure. An over-oxidized oolong becomes a generic, malty black tea, losing its valuable floral identity. And an over-fermented black tea, though dark, becomes a "soft" and "dull" liquor, devoid of the briskness that defines its quality. The final flavor profile in a cup of tea is, therefore, a direct reflection of the master's ability to precisely control this enzymatic engine, halting it at the exact moment of perfect balance.

---

Comparative Analysis of Processing Outcomes

This table (also seen in our Disruption guide) summarizes how the management of oxidation (or its prevention) dictates the final chemical and sensory profile of the tea.

Table 1: Comparative Analysis of Processing, Biochemistry, and Chemical Outcomes of Camellia sinensis

Tea Type	Key Processing Step (The "Fork")	Disruption Philosophy & Method	Oxidation Level (%)	PPO/POD Enzyme Status	Dominant Polyphenol Profile	Primary Sensory Profile
Green Tea	Shaqing (Heat-Fixing)	Prevention. Heat (steaming/pan-firing) denatures enzymes before rolling (for shape).	0% (Prevented)	Denatured (Inactivated by heat)	Catechins (EGCG, EGC)	Grassy, vegetal, marine, toasty, nutty
Oolong Tea	Yaoqing (Bruising) & Tanliang (Resting)	Partial & Controlled. Gentle tossing/tumbling bruises only leaf edges. Iterative cycles of disruption and rest.	10-70% (Partial)	Active (Localized). Active only at bruised edges; controlled by rest/temp cycles.	Oolongtheanins & Theasinensins (plus retained Catechins)	Floral, fruity, nutty, roasted, complex
Black Tea (Orthodox)	Orthodox Rolling	Total & Controlled. Machine rolling twists and wrings whole leaves. Coats leaf in own juices.	~100% (Full)	Fully Active. Mixed completely with substrates.	Theaflavins (TFs) & Thearubigins (TRs)	Nuanced, malty, brisk, complex flavor
Black Tea (CTC)	Crush, Tear, Curl (CTC)	Total & Industrial. High-speed toothed rollers pulverize leaf into granules.	100% (Full & Rapid)	Fully Active. Mixed instantly and completely.	Theaflavins (TFs) & Thearubigins (TRs) (often high TR/TF ratio)	Bold, strong, malty, astringent, generic

---

Works Cited

1. https://iteaworld.com/blogs/basic-knowledge-of-oolong-tea/a-beginner-s-guide-how-to-choose-the-best-oolong-tea-by-oxidation-level
2. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8840101/
3. https://openbiotechnologyjournal.com/VOLUME/14/PAGE/78/FULLTEXT/
4. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/379680509_Comparative_evaluation_of_the_impact_of_processing_methods_in_determining_the_levels_of_health_promoting_chemical_constituents_and_quality_of_green_tea
5. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10743253/
6. https://www.teaclass.com/lesson_0106.html
7. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2946098/
8. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383753044_Biochemistry_of_Tea_Leaves_and_Tea_Processing_Technology
9. https://www.eatthis.com/black-tea-vs-green-tea/
10. https://www.revivalteacompany.com/blogs/tea-101/black-tea-vs-green-tea
11. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369975412_A_comprehensive_review_of_polyphenol_oxidase_in_tea_Camellia_sinensis_Physiological_characteristics_oxidation_manufacturing_and_biosynthesis_of_functional_constituents
12. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10887689/
13. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/308993550_Peroxidase_Can_Perform_the_Hydroxylation_Step_in_the_Oxidative_Cascade_during_Oxidation_of_Tea_Catechins
14. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Principle-differences-between-green-oolong-and-black-tea-processing_fig3_260115712
15. https://www.wanlingteahouse.com/blogs/tea-articles/fixation-aka-kill-green-tea-production-and-processing
16. https://www.revivalteacompany.com/blogs/tea-101/black-tea-vs-green-tea#:~:text=After%20harvest%2C%20the%20leaves%20are,closer%20to%20its%20natural%20form.
17. https://teaepicure.com/killing-the-green/
18. https://teaepicure.com/tea-leaves-oxidation/
19. https://taiwanleaftea.com/info/kill-green-in-tea-production
20. https://artfultea.com/blogs/tea-wisdom/tea-oxidation
21. https://www.beantowntea.com/beantown-tea-blog/2017/11/22/the-tea-making-process-of-bruising
22. https://www.scielo.br/j/cta/a/5s9NjmJwVYMVMjDC8xvmysq/
23. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10552528/
24. https://narendratea.com/what-is-orthodox-tea-and-how-to-relish-its-taste-and-benefits/
25. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267011538_Impact_of_maceration_under_low_temperature_on_quality_of_tea
26. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4375181/