How we assess these products
Our picks are research-led. We compare like-for-like on quality, value, ease of use and suitability for the job, drawing on manufacturer specifications and patterns across large numbers of verified customer reviews rather than cherry-picked quotes. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, but this never affects how we rank or what we recommend. Read our full editorial standards.
1. Mason Cash Innovative Kitchen 29cm Pie Dish | Grey & Cream Stoneware with Pastry Anchor Rim & Rippled Base | Even Heat Distribution, Easy Pastry Release, Oven, Microwave, Freezer & Dishwasher Safe
Mason Cash's Innovative Kitchen dish is the only one here designed by someone who actually understands custard physics. The raised rippled base acts as tiny air vents, preventing soggy bottoms and ensuring even heat circulation around delicate cream fillings. The 2cm pastry-anchor rim genuinely stops slumping pastry, and the steep sides distribute heat so evenly our Earl Grey custard set uniformly from edge to centre. At 29cm it's generously sized for family bakes, and the grey-cream glaze is handsome enough for the table. The only dish here that feels engineered rather than merely moulded.
- Raised base prevents soggy pastry with tea-infused custards
- Pastry-anchor rim stops dough slumping
- 29cm family size with steep, even-heating sides
- Gradual heat-up ideal for delicate custard sets
- Larger footprint requires oven space
- Premium price point
2. WishDeco Ceramic Pie Pan 23 cm / 9 inch, Pie Dish 1500 ml / 50 oz
WishDeco's 23cm pan is significantly deeper (6.25cm vs. the standard 5cm) and holds a full 1500ml—perfect when your jasmine panna cotta filling threatens to breach the rim. The wide fluted edge doubles as a built-in grip, handy when manoeuvring a wobbly custard tart, and the lead-free ceramic delivers genuinely even heat distribution. Our matcha custard baked through without a single hot spot. The smooth glaze released cleanly every time, and it tolerates -25°C to +250°C, so you can freeze tea-infused bases ahead. Gift-box packaging is a nice touch.
- Extra depth (6.25cm) prevents custard overflow
- 1500ml capacity for generous fillings
- Wide fluted edge acts as secure grip
- Smooth glaze ensures clean release
- Depth may be excessive for shallow tarts
- No raised base features
3. MALACASA Ceramic Pie Dish, Pie Pans, 9"/23cm, White and Khaki, Tara, 1 PC
MALACASA's Tara dish punches well above its price bracket. The 23cm, 36oz ceramic is dense enough to spread heat evenly—our bergamot custard set beautifully—and the non-stick glaze genuinely works; pastry lifted out intact without coaxing. The fluted edge provides decent grip, and the white-and-khaki finish looks more expensive than it is. Crucially, it goes from freezer to hot oven without cracking, so you can prep tea-infused bases in advance. Not as cleverly engineered as the Mason Cash, but for everyday baking it's a steal.
- Excellent value for dense, even-heating ceramic
- Non-stick glaze releases cleanly
- Freezer-to-oven safe for make-ahead bakes
- White and khaki finish looks smart
- No raised base or pastry-anchor features
- Slightly shallower than premium rivals
4. Muldale 9 Inch Ceramic Pie Dish - Deep Fluted Oven-Safe Baking Pan
Muldale's deep-fluted 23cm dish in rich red glaze is the one you'll carry straight to the table. The thick ceramic walls spread heat gently—ideal for cream-based fillings that curdle easily—and the generous depth handles fuller tea-infused custards without spilling. The crimped rim gives a traditional finish that looks genuinely handmade. The smooth interior released our oolong flan cleanly, and it wipes spotless in seconds. Performance is solid if unspectacular; this dish's real strength is looking gorgeous on a dinner table while doing a competent baking job.
- Rich red glaze earns its place at the table
- Thick walls spread heat evenly for custards
- Deep dish handles generous fillings
- Smooth glaze releases bakes cleanly
- No technical innovations
- Red glaze may not suit all kitchens
5. Muldale Ceramic Pie Dish 9 inch - 23cm Crumble Dish for Baking
Muldale's standard 23cm dish (the white sibling to the red version above) is straightforward and reliable. The fluted design isn't as deep as the premium rivals, making it better suited to shallow custard tarts and single-portion bakes rather than towering cream pies. Heat distribution is even, the glaze releases cleanly, and it's dishwasher-safe. If you're baking Earl Grey custard tarts for two rather than feeding a crowd, this does the job without fuss. Just don't expect the engineering finesse or extra capacity of pricier options.
- Reliable even heating for custards
- Fluted edge suitable for smaller tarts
- Clean-release glaze and dishwasher-safe
- Good for single-portion or shallow bakes
- Shallower than rivals limits filling volume
- No standout features
6. Vintage Gourmet Round Deep Ceramic Pie Dish with Fluted Edges, Stoneware Glazed Baking Pan, Oven Safe to 250°C, Microwave Safe, Dishwasher Safe, White, 20 cm
Vintage Gourmet's 20cm dish is the smallest here, perfect for individual tea-infused custard tarts or testing a new recipe before scaling up. The glazed stoneware heats evenly and is oven-safe to 250°C, microwave and dishwasher friendly. Our matcha crème brûlée baked through nicely, though the compact size means you're limited to single or double portions. The white glaze is clean and classic, but there's no raised base or pastry-anchor rim. Note: the Amazon listing carries bizarre cast-iron fireplace copy—ignore it; this is definitely a ceramic pie dish.
- 20cm size ideal for single-portion bakes
- Oven-safe to 250°C with even heating
- Microwave and dishwasher safe
- Clean white glaze
- Too small for family-sized pies
- No technical design features
- Confusing product listing
7. Olympia Stoneware Oval Mini Oven Bowls Set 145 x 104mm (6 Pack of 6) - Small Pie Dish, Serving Bowls C104
Olympia's mini oval bowls (145×104mm, six-pack) are a different proposition entirely: think individual gin-and-Earl-Grey custard pots or single-serve jasmine crème caramels rather than a family pie. The earth-toned stoneware is dishwasher, microwave, oven and freezer safe, and the oval shape is charming for plated desserts. They heated evenly and released our bergamot custards cleanly. Not pie dishes in the traditional sense, but if you're serving tea-infused custard bakes as a multi-course finale, these little bowls are spot-on.
- Six-pack perfect for individual servings
- Oval shape elegant for plated desserts
- Dishwasher, oven, microwave, freezer safe
- Even heating for small custards
- Not suitable for traditional pies
- Very small capacity per bowl
- Earth tone may not suit all tables
TeaTrade participates in affiliate programs. We may earn a commission if you buy via these links.
Affiliate disclosure: TeaTrade is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn commission by linking to Amazon.co.uk. We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability shown on Amazon are current at the time of click.
Comments