← Back to Learning Hub

Why Does My Pu-erh Tea Taste "Fishy"? (And How to Fix It)

For a new Pu-erh drinker, few experiences are as jarring as unwrapping a cake of tea, expecting the promised notes of dark chocolate and ancient forests, and instead being hit with the distinct aroma of a dockside fish market. In the West, this "fishy" characteristic is the single most common reason consumers abandon Pu-erh tea entirely.

However, this aroma does not mean your tea has been stored near seafood, nor does it necessarily mean the tea is ruined. It is usually a byproduct of biochemistry—specifically, the fermentation process of Shou (Ripe) Pu-erh. Understanding why this happens distinguishes the casual drinker from the connoisseur, and in many cases, the tea can be salvaged.

A dark, ripe Shou Pu-erh tea cake, often associated with earthy or 'Dui Wei' aromas.

Key Takeaways

  • It's a Shou (Ripe) Pu-erh Problem: The "fishy" smell is almost exclusively found in Shou (Ripe) Pu-erh, not Sheng (Raw) Pu-erh. If your Sheng smells fishy, it's likely fake or has been stored improperly.
  • The Cause: The odor is caused by Trimethylamine (TMA), a chemical byproduct of microbial metabolism during the "Wo Dui" (wet piling) fermentation process.
  • Is it Bad? Often, it's just "Dui Wei" (Pile Smell), a sign that the tea is very young (under 3 years) and the aroma hasn't dissipated yet. It is not a sign of mold.
  • How to Fix It (Patience): The best fix is to break the cake into chunks and let it "air-out" in a paper bag or cardboard box for a few weeks. The smell will often vanish.
  • How to Fix It (Brewing): To drink it now, use two fast, boiling-water "rinses" (steep for 5 seconds, discard water) before your first infusion to wash away the volatile compounds.

The Chemical Culprit: Trimethylamine

The specific chemical responsible for the fishy odor in Pu-erh is trimethylamine (TMA). This is an organic compound that is indeed found in decomposing fish, but in the context of tea, it is a byproduct of microbial metabolism during the fermentation process.

As detailed in our main Pu-erh guide, Shou Pu-erh undergoes Wo Dui (wet piling), where tea leaves are piled, moistened, and subjected to heat and microbial activity. Under these intense conditions, if the fermentation piles are not managed with absolute precision regarding oxygen and temperature, the microbial breakdown of organic matter can produce TMA.

It is important to note that this is almost exclusively a problem with Shou (Ripe) Pu-erh. A Sheng (Raw) Pu-erh should smell of dried fruit, hay, or camphor. If a Sheng Pu-erh smells fishy, it is likely a fake (cheap Shou passed off as aged Sheng) or has been stored in disastrously improper conditions.

Diagnosing the Cause

Not all fishy smells are created equal. To determine if your tea is fixable, you must identify the source of the odor.

The "Dui Wei" (Pile Smell)

The most common cause is simply youth. Freshly fermented Shou Pu-erh (under 1–3 years old) often retains the "Dui Wei" or "heap flavor." This is the residual aroma of the fermentation floor—a mix of ammonia, damp earth, and yes, a fishy funk.

The Verdict: This is a temporary flaw. The tea is likely safe and will improve significantly with air and time.

Improper Fermentation (Bad Processing)

If the Wo Dui process is rushed, or if the piles are allowed to become too anaerobic (lacking oxygen), the bacterial cultures can shift toward those that produce excessive TMA. This often happens with low-quality "tuo cha" (nests) or cheap loose leaf teas produced without strict sanitary oversight.

The Verdict: This is a quality defect. While airing may help, the underlying flavor structure may always be muddy or unpleasant.

Is It Safe to Drink?

Generally, yes. While the aroma of trimethylamine is unpleasant, drinking the tea will not harm you, provided there is no visible mold (fuzzy white, yellow, or green growth). However, if the smell is accompanied by visible mildew or a reaction that triggers allergies (some drinkers report histamine-like reactions to bad fermentation), it should be discarded.

Protocols for "Fixing" the Tea

If you have a cake that smells fishy but shows no sign of mold, do not throw it away immediately. Use the following protocols to rehabilitate the leaf.

The "Air-Out" Method (Resting)

This is the most effective solution for "Dui Wei."

  1. Break it Down: Do not leave the tea compressed. Use a tea pick or needle to gently break the cake or brick into chunks.
  2. Container: Place the chunks in a jar, but do not seal the lid. Alternatively, place them in a paper bag or a cardboard box. The goal is to allow airflow while protecting the tea from dust.
  3. Wait: Volatile compounds like TMA dissipate over time. Check the tea after two weeks. If the smell persists, leave it for a month or even a year. Many "un-drinkable" teas transform into rich, sweet brews after 6 to 12 months of air exposure.

Expert Tip: The Rinse Protocol (Brewing Fix)

If you want to drink the tea immediately, you can mitigate the flavor through your brewing technique.

  • High Heat: Use boiling water (100°C / 212°F).
  • The Double Rinse: Perform two aggressive "flash rinses." Pour the boiling water over the leaves and pour it off immediately (within 5 seconds). Do this twice.
  • Discard: Do not drink the rinse liquid.

This washes away the surface dust and the most volatile surface compounds (including the fishy aroma) before you begin the actual brewing.

The "Nuclear" Option (Roasting)

For cheaper teas that refuse to lose their funk, some enthusiasts employ a roasting method. Placing the tea in an air fryer or oven at very low heat (around 180°F / 82°C) for 20 minutes can drive off the volatile TMA.

Warning: This will halt any future aging potential of the tea and may give it a "roasted" or "wet stone" flavor, but it effectively kills the fishiness.

Summary Table: Action Plan

Symptom Likely Cause Recommended Action
Fishy smell in Sheng (Raw) Fake tea or storage rot Discard. Do not consume.
Fishy smell in young Shou (<3 yrs) "Dui Wei" (Pile Smell) Rest. Break up and air out for 2–4 weeks.
Fishy smell in aged Shou (>5 yrs) Bad processing/storage Rinse. Try the double rinse method. If it persists, discard.
Visible Mold + Fishy Smell Contamination Discard. Health risk.

Related Learning

Want to know more? Dive deeper with these expert guides from our Learning Hub.

Sheng (Raw) vs. Shou (Ripe) Pu-erh: The Main Guide

The Expert Guide to Yunnan (The Home of Pu-erh)

A Scientific Guide to Mastering Tea-Brewing (Gongfu)