← Back to Reviews

The Best Ingredients for DIY Earl Grey: Oils, Peels & Plants

Crucial Safety Warning

Never use standard essential oils from the aromatherapy aisle for tea. They may contain solvents or additives that are toxic if ingested. You MUST use "Food Grade" or "Flavor Grade" organic oils derived from Citrus bergamia.

Why make your own Earl Grey? Control. Most commercial blends use synthetic flavorings that taste like perfume. By using real, food-grade Bergamot oil, you can create a tea with the authentic, zesty complexity of the Italian citrus fruit.

We have sourced the essential materials you need to become a tea blender at home: the safest oils, the best dried peels for texture, and even the live plant if you want to grow your own "Wild Bergamot."

A bottle of bergamot essential oil with a dropper next to dried citrus peels.
Best Essential Oil (Food Grade)
LorAnn Bergamot Oil

1. LorAnn Oils Natural Bergamot Oil

★★★★★ (The Industry Standard)

LorAnn is the go-to brand for professional confectioners and bakers. This is a 100% natural, food-grade essential oil. It is incredibly potent—you only need 4-6 drops to scent 100g of tea leaves. It delivers that authentic, sharp citrus aroma without the soapy aftertaste of cheap synthetics.

Pros:
  • Certified Food Grade
  • Highly concentrated (value for money)
  • Clean citrus profile
Cons:
  • Sold in small bottles (but lasts forever)
Check Price on LorAnn
Best Dried Peel
Frontier Co-op Dried Orange Peel

2. Frontier Co-op Dried Orange/Citrus Peel

★★★★☆ (Visual & Texture)

While the oil provides the aroma, dried peels provide the visual beauty and a subtle background sweetness. Since pure Bergamot peel is hard to find dried, high-quality Seville Orange peel is the traditional substitute used in many "Lady Grey" blends to add body to the mix.

Pros:
  • Adds visual flair to the blend
  • Acts as a "fixative" for the oil
  • Organic and non-irradiated
Cons:
  • Not as aromatic as the oil itself
Check Price on Frontier Co-Op
Best Curing Equipment
Amber Glass Jars

3. Amber Glass Wide-Mouth Jars (16oz)

★★★★★ (Essential Tool)

You cannot brew your DIY Earl Grey immediately; it needs to "cure" for at least a week so the oil penetrates the tea leaves. Amber glass is essential because Bergamot oil is photosensitive and degrades in sunlight. These jars seal tight to prevent the volatile aromas from escaping.

Pros:
  • UV protection for oils
  • Airtight seal for curing
  • Inert glass (won't absorb odors)
Cons:
  • Breakable
Check Price on Amazon
Best Live Plant (Gardening)
Monarda Didyma Seeds

4. Monarda Didyma (Bee Balm) Seeds

★★★★☆ (The Native Alternative)

Did you know there is a flower that smells exactly like Earl Grey? Monarda Didyma, also known as "Wild Bergamot," is a mint-family plant native to North America. The leaves and red flowers can be dried and added to black tea for a unique, homegrown Earl Grey flavor.

Pros:
  • Grow your own flavoring
  • Beautiful red flowers
  • Attracts pollinators
Cons:
  • Flavor is herbal, distinct from citrus bergamot
Check Price on Amazon
Best Precision Tool
Glass Pipettes

5. Calibrated Glass Droppers

★★★★☆ (For Consistency)

One extra drop of Bergamot oil can ruin a batch of tea, making it taste like cleaning fluid. Precision is key. These glass pipettes allow you to count drops accurately and reach the bottom of your oil bottle without waste.

Pros:
  • Prevents ruining batches
  • Easy to clean
  • Reusable
Cons:
  • Fragile glass
Check Price on Amazon

TeaTrade participates in affiliate programs. We may earn a commission if you buy via these links.

Read Next: The Method

Now you have the materials, how do you actually blend it?

How to Make Your Own Earl Grey: The Art of Scenting Tea

Review: The Best Pre-Made Earl Grey Teas

Assam Tea Guide: The Best Base for Blending