← Back to Reviews

The 6 Best Earl Grey Teas of 2025: Real Bergamot vs. Flavoring

Does your Earl Grey taste like soap? That means it uses synthetic perfume. We tested the top brands to find the ones using real Italian Bergamot oil for a zesty, authentic cup.

Who Invented It?

Earl Grey is the most famous flavored tea in history, named after Prime Minister Charles Grey. Discover the legend (and the British politics behind it) in our guide: How Tea Conquered Britain →

Part 1: The Best Loose Leaf (For The Connoisseur)

Loose leaf Earl Grey allows you to see the blue cornflowers and citrus peel. These blends use a higher quality base tea than what you find in bags.

The Gold Standard
Vahdam Earl Grey Citrus Loose Leaf

1. Vahdam Earl Grey Citrus

★★★★★ (Best Overall)

Vahdam combines premium Indian Black Tea with 100% natural Bergamot oil. The result is refreshing, not perfumey. Because the leaves are vacuum-sealed at the source in India, the citrus aroma is incredibly potent when you open the bag.

Pros:
  • Real Bergamot Oil (No "Soap" taste)
  • Vacuum sealed freshness
  • Beautiful long-leaf tea
Cons:
  • Needs a teapot/infuser
Check Price on Amazon
The Luxury Gift
Mariage Frères Earl Grey French Blue

2. Mariage Frères "Earl Grey French Blue"

★★★★☆ (Most Elegant)

If you want to impress a guest, serve this. This legendary French tea house adds vivid blue cornflowers to the blend. It is smoother, silkier, and more floral than a standard British Earl Grey. It feels like velvet in the mouth.

Pros:
  • Stunning visual appearance (Blue flowers)
  • Very low astringency
  • Iconic black tin (reusable)
Cons:
  • Very expensive (Luxury item)
  • Harder to find in supermarkets
Check Price on Amazon
The "Dessert" Tea
Cream Earl Grey with Vanilla

3. Cream Earl Grey (Vanilla Blend)

★★★★★ (Best with Milk)

This is a modern twist that is taking over the market. It blends traditional Bergamot with a hint of Vanilla. The result is a "London Fog" latte taste straight out of the pot. It is sweet, comforting, and perfect for people who find regular Earl Grey too sharp.

Pros:
  • Naturally sweet (Vanilla notes)
  • Amazing as a latte
  • Softens the citrus bite
Cons:
  • Purists might find it too sweet
Check Price on Amazon

Part 2: The Best Tea Bags (For Convenience)

You don't always have time for a teapot. These bags deliver real flavor without the dust.

Best Premium Bag
Teapigs Darjeeling Earl Grey

4. Teapigs Darjeeling Earl Grey

★★★★★ (Best Quality)

Most Earl Greys use a generic, strong black tea base. Teapigs uses Darjeeling from the Himalayas. This makes the tea lighter, more floral, and more "champagne-like." The biodegradable temple bag allows for whole leaves, not dust.

Pros:
  • Premium Darjeeling base
  • Whole leaf "Temple" bag
  • Plastic-free packaging
Cons:
  • Expensive per cup
  • Lighter body (less strong)
Check Price on Amazon
The Classic
Twinings Earl Grey Tea Bags

5. Twinings Earl Grey (The Original)

★★★★☆ (Most Reliable)

Twinings literally invented this tea (according to them). It is the taste most people grew up with. It is light, zesty, and extremely consistent. While it doesn't have the complexity of loose leaf, it is the perfect reliable daily drinker.

Pros:
  • The classic flavor profile
  • Very affordable
  • Widely available
Cons:
  • Can taste slightly artificial to connoisseurs
  • Standard paper tea bags
Check Price on Amazon
Best Decaf
Clipper Organic Decaf Earl Grey

6. Clipper Organic Decaf Earl Grey

★★★★☆ (Best Evening)

Want the citrus taste before bed? Most decaf teas use harsh chemicals to strip the caffeine, which ruins the flavor. Clipper uses a natural CO2 process and Organic ingredients. It retains the zesty Bergamot punch without the jitters.

Pros:
  • Organic & Fairtrade
  • Natural Decaf process (No chemicals)
  • Unbleached bags
Cons:
  • Flavor is slightly lighter than caf versions
Check Price on Amazon

The Verdict