← Back to Reviews

Harney & Sons vs. Fortnum & Mason: The Transatlantic Tea Battle

Loose Leaf vs. Sachets

Fortnum & Mason is famous for their loose leaf caddies (tins), which offer the best value and flavor but require a teapot. Harney & Sons often uses silken pyramid sachets, which are more convenient for single cups but slightly more expensive per gram.

It is a battle of heritage vs. innovation. In the blue corner, we have Fortnum & Mason, the London department store founded in 1707 that holds a Royal Warrant to supply tea to the British Monarch. In the black corner, we have Harney & Sons, the American family business founded in 1983 that revolutionized the US tea market with unique, bold flavor blends.

Is the "Old World" prestige of Fortnum's worth the import price? Or does the "New World" creativity of Harney & Sons offer a better daily brew? We tasted their flagship blends side-by-side to find out.

A tin of Fortnum & Mason Royal Blend next to a tin of Harney & Sons Paris tea.
Best Traditional Blend
Fortnum & Mason Royal Blend Tea Tin

1. Fortnum & Mason Royal Blend

★★★★★ (The King of Breakfast)

First blended for King Edward VII in 1902, this is the definition of a sophisticated breakfast tea. It blends low-grown Flowery Pekoe from Ceylon (which adds a honey-like lift) with maltier Assam. The result is smooth, incredibly rich, and robust enough to handle milk without losing its character.

Pros:
  • Historic recipe (100+ years)
  • Smooth, honey-like notes
  • Iconic Eau de Nil tin
Cons:
  • Premium price point
  • Traditional profile (no fancy flavors)
Check Price on Amazon
Best Flavored Black Tea
Harney & Sons Paris Tea Tin

2. Harney & Sons Paris

★★★★★ (Dessert in a Cup)

This is Harney's masterpiece. A tribute to Parisian tea shops, it starts with a black tea base and adds vanilla, caramel, and a hint of lemony bergamot. The aroma alone is intoxicating. It tastes like an Earl Grey that went to a patisserie. It is sweet, complex, and utterly unique.

Pros:
  • Incredible vanilla/caramel aroma
  • Approachable for non-tea drinkers
  • Beautiful tin design
Cons:
  • Contains natural/artificial flavorings
  • Might be too sweet for purists
Check Price on Amazon
Best Earl Grey
Fortnum & Mason Earl Grey Classic Tin

3. Fortnum & Mason Earl Grey Classic

★★★★☆ (The Aristocrat)

British Prime Minister Charles Grey gave his name to this tea in the 1830s, and Fortnum's version is as classic as it gets. It uses simple, high-quality black tea scented with pure bergamot oil. It is refreshing, zesty, and lacks the heavy "creamy" vanilla notes found in modern American versions. A clean, afternoon classic.

Pros:
  • Pure, zesty bergamot flavor
  • Refreshing afternoon tea
  • No artificial aftertaste
Cons:
  • Lighter body than "Supreme" blends
Check Price on Amazon
Best Unique / Spiced
Harney & Sons Hot Cinnamon Spice Tin

4. Harney & Sons Hot Cinnamon Spice

★★★★☆ (The Firestarter)

This is Harney's most popular flavored tea for a reason. It is an assertive blend of black tea, three types of cinnamon, orange peel, and sweet cloves. It is naturally sweet (no sugar added) and leaves a distinct "hot" tingle on the tongue, similar to Red Hots candy. Perfect for cold winter days.

Pros:
  • Intense, warming flavor
  • Naturally sweet (sugar-free)
  • Great circulation booster
Cons:
  • Can be overpowering
  • Clove notes are strong
Check Price on Amazon
Best Gift Set
Fortnum & Mason Famous Tea Selection

5. Fortnum & Mason Famous Tea Selection

★★★★★ (The Ultimate Gift)

If you can't decide, or you need to buy a gift for a tea lover, this is the answer. It contains 60 tea bags across 6 of their most famous blends, including Royal Blend, Earl Grey Classic, and Breakfast Blend. The presentation box radiates luxury and allows you to tour the history of British tea in one package.

Pros:
  • Includes 6 different classic blends
  • Stunning gift presentation
  • Great way to taste-test
Cons:
  • Tea bags (not loose leaf)
Check Price on Amazon

TeaTrade participates in affiliate programs. We may earn a commission if you buy via these links.