← Back to Reviews

Tetley vs. Yorkshire vs. PG Tips: Which is the Best Everyday Tea?

Hard Water Warning

If you live in London or the South East, standard tea can taste flat or develop a scum layer due to calcium. Yorkshire Tea offers a specific "Hard Water" blend that uses African teas to punch through the mineral content.

It is the debate that divides offices and families across the UK: Which "Builder's Brew" is best? For decades, the "Big Three"—Yorkshire Tea, PG Tips, and Tetley—have dominated the kitchen cupboard.

But the landscape has shifted. Yorkshire Tea has overtaken PG Tips as the nation's favorite. Meanwhile, PG Tips recently controversially reformulated their bags to "brew in 60 seconds", and budget options like Asda Everyday are winning blind taste tests. We put the titans to the test to see which bag belongs in your mug.

Boxes of Yorkshire Tea, Tetley, and PG Tips stacked on a kitchen counter with mugs of tea.
Best Overall
Yorkshire Tea Red Label Box

1. Yorkshire Tea (Red Label)

★★★★★ (The Nation's Favorite)

There is a reason this has become the UK's number one brew. Yorkshire Tea strikes the perfect balance between strength and flavor. It is significantly stronger than its competitors, producing a rich, malty "biscuit" taste that stands up perfectly to milk and sugar. It doesn't taste like dust; it tastes like tea.

Pros:
  • Robust, full-bodied flavor
  • Excellent color (even with milk)
  • Hard water variant available
Cons:
  • Slightly more expensive than Tetley
Check Price on Amazon
Best Premium Choice
Yorkshire Gold Tea Box

2. Yorkshire Gold

★★★★★ (Luxury Brew)

If the Red Label is a reliable sedan, Gold is the luxury tourer. It blends teas from the top 10 tea gardens in Assam, Kenya, and Rwanda. The result is smoother, brighter, and more complex than the original. It lacks the harsh astringency of cheaper blends, making it drinkable even without milk.

Pros:
  • Smoother, less bitter taste
  • High-quality leaf origins
  • Rich golden liquor
Cons:
  • Premium price point
Check Price on Amazon
Best Budget Pick
Tetley Original Tea Bags

3. Tetley Original

★★★★☆ (Reliable & Mellow)

Tetley remains a solid choice for those who find Yorkshire Tea too aggressive. It has a mellower, slightly fruitier profile. While some critics find it a bit "cardboard-like" when black, it transforms well with a splash of milk. It is frequently on offer, making it a great budget staple.

Pros:
  • Very affordable
  • Mellow, non-bitter taste
  • Great with sugar
Cons:
  • Can taste weak if under-brewed
Check Price on Amazon
Controversial Pick
PG Tips Original New Blend

4. PG Tips Original (New Blend)

★★★☆☆ (Changed Recipe)

PG Tips recently ditched their famous pyramid bags for a new square design that claims to "brew in 60 seconds." Unfortunately, many long-time fans find the new blend lacks body and depth, often describing it as "bland" or "dusty". It brews fast, but the flavor sacrifices are noticeable compared to Yorkshire.

Pros:
  • Brews very quickly
  • Biodegradable bags
Cons:
  • New blend lacks depth
  • Thinner body than previous version
Check Price on Amazon

TeaTrade participates in affiliate programs. We may earn a commission if you buy via these links.